A wonderful essay by Tara Isabella Burton in The New Atlantis on Effective Altruism, the rationalist and now post-rationalist online communities, and the turn they’ve taken toward the transcendent.
Paywalled, but TNA is well worth a sub for those interested in moral engagement with technology. 🔗
Current listening: Brian Blade, Mama Rosa.
I’ve loved this singer-songwriter-Gospel album from a world-class jazz drummer. 🎶
Finished reading: Laurus by Eugene Vodolazkin.
My second read; it’s as beautiful and profound as it was the first time through.📚
The Temptation in the Wilderness, part 1 (Good Teacher #3) ✝️
Then Jesus was led up by the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil. And after fasting forty days and forty nights, he was hungry. And the tempter came and said to him, “If you are the Son of God, command these stones to become loaves of bread. But he answered, “It is written
‘Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God.’”
Then the devil took him to the holy city and set him on the pinnacle of the temple, and said to him, “If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down, for it is written,
‘He will command his angels concerning you,’
and
‘On their hands they will bear you up, lest you strike your foot against a stone.’”
Jesus said to him, “Again it is written, ‘You shall not put the Lord your God to the test.’” Again, the devil took him to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their glory. And he said to him, “All these I will give you, if you will fall down and worship me.” Then Jesus said to him, “Be gone, Satan! For it is written,
‘You shall worship the Lord your God and him only shall you serve.”
Last week’s post on the baptism of Jesus emphasized the new life that comes through humility. I’m going to spend a few weeks on the story above, because it brilliantly conveys the struggle we each face when trying to build that new life, to start on a new path.
(Remember, the point of this newsletter isn’t to convince you that the devil exists, or even that the events depicted here in these stories actually happened. Rather, we’re just seeking the wisdom available to us in Jesus’ life and teaching.)
How many times have you tried to change your life? How many times has your life actually, significantly changed? Are you still on that new path?
I’ve tried many times. Some attempts have stuck, and my life’s better as a result. Other attempts I’d rather forget, even as I’m reminded regularly of these struggles. Each time, though, I find that my resolve is immediately confronted by the forces of fear and inertia. It’s why there are a zillion books on keeping your resolutions, how to make habits stick, take control of your life, beat your phone addiction, etc.
Simply put, there’s no easy way to change. Even when I embrace the new life available to me, I can be certain that the temptation to stay the same will be profound. A new path is uncertain, risky.
The story today depicts Jesus himself facing three temptations: turn stones into wine; fling himself to certain death and command angels to save him; bow down and worship the devil.
In some ways, this first temptation is the easiest to understand. After all, Jesus had been fasting in the wilderness (some translations use the word “desert”) for 40 days. Why not just break the fast? What’s the point of being so hard on yourself?
Well, as Jesus says later in this book, “The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.”
Willing . . . to do what? Too weak . . . for what task? For the work of changing yourself, your life. We crave comfort. We’re all uncomfortable with the unfamiliar, even when we know it’s a better place to be. Our bodies insist that we don’t upset things too much.
Jesus specifically sought out the temptation, and went to the wilderness—literally, the unknown and unfamiliar place—to find it. One simple truth here is that there’s no easy way to change your life, even when you have a vision of the new life that’s available. There will be temptation to go back to the familiar. To compromise, because what’s the point, really?
Jesus’ example suggests that the way through is to embrace the temptation we know is coming. To seek it out, on our own terms—empowered by that vision of new life—so that we aren’t caught off guard when confronting it.
- What temptations do you expect to encounter as you seek to change your life?
- How will you resist them?
Baptism & new life (Good Teacher #2) ✝️
Then Jesus came from Galilee to the Jordan to John, to be baptized by him. John would have prevented him, saying “I need to be baptized by you, and do you come to me?” But Jesus answered him, “Let it be so now, for thus it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness.” Then he consented. And when Jesus was baptized, immediately he went up from the water, and behold, the heavens were opened to him, and he saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove and coming to rest on him; and behold, a voice from heaven said, “This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.
~Matthew 3:13-17
Jesus’ baptism displays a major theme of his life and teaching: the humble are lifted up, and the mighty and prideful are undermined. John believes he isn’t worthy to baptize Jesus; this is what makes him worthy. Jesus recognizes this and humbles himself to be baptized by John.
His baptism is the start of Jesus’ work. Baptism—going under the water; coming up out of the water—symbolizes transformation: from death to life, from a life hidden in the depths to one public and open.
After his baptism “the heavens were opened”: a new sort of life became possible. A new start is always available and open to me, too. But only when I humbly commit to being transformed. Only when I recognize the death in my life—my old way of living, my destructive patterns of behavior.
It will come through people we might be tempted to overlook and ignore. But if we embrace the vision of that abundant life, and open ourselves to those around us, there is new, abundant life available.
- What paths of death or destruction are you on? How is pride preventing you from a fresh start?
- What people are you ignoring who might offer transformation?
- How do you imagine a fresh, new, abundant life for yourself?
I’m heading to Chicago this weekend for a birthday celebration with my father & brother. I’m eager for some bookstore recommendations. Any advice, Chicagoans? 📚
Welcome to the Good Teacher (Good Teacher #1) ✝️
In this newsletter, the goal is to consider Jesus’ teaching: what makes it worth following now, 2,000 after Jesus lived? Can it speak to us today? Does it have anything to offer our world?
This newsletter won’t be about institutional Christianity; it won’t be about “spirituality,” whatever that means. Rather, we’re simply trying to answer the question “How should I live?” The goal isn’t to convert you to anything—other than to a better life.
You don’t need to assume anything about the historical truth of the stories and teachings we consider. That’s a discussion for another day. You can consider Jesus’ words entirely historical, entirely fictional, or somewhere in between.
My only assumption is that Jesus was a great & wise teacher, so it’s worthwhile to reflect on how to apply his teaching to my life. That’s what we’ll do together here.
(Even if you don’t share that one assumption, you’re welcome to join. Perhaps our reflections will help you make a fresh judgment for yourself.)
Realizing I should be maintaining issues of my newsletter here on my blog, not just on Substack, in case things fall apart, as they tend to do. So I’ll start re-posting 1-2 a week.
The newsletter is on the ethical teachings of Jesus. It doesn’t assume any religious belief or perspective.
Austin Klein won’t be hiring a virtual assistant anytime soon. 🔗
R.I.P. Ahmad Jamal, one of the greatest and perhaps my absolute favorite jazz pianist.
My dad used to play “Stolen Moments” at night while I was going to sleep. I’ve loved Jamal ever since. 🎶 🔗
The best AI app wouldn’t be an everything app. It would be a nothing app—so smart it helped me do nothing on my screens and more in the real world. 🔗
Everything Iain McGilchrist has to say is worth considering, but I can’t recommend his conversation with Dark Mountain Project co-founder Dougald Hine highly enough.
It’s about climate change, the place of science in modernity, AI, and much more. 🔗
On Brad East’s blog, Denise Levertov’s Good Friday poem “On a Theme from Julian’s Chapter XX”:
Every sorrow and desolation He saw, and sorrowed in kinship.
✝️📚🔗
[Early book collectors] supported the lively culture of book hunting that still goes on, diminished but not dead yet, in the auction houses and antiquarian bookshops of New York, Boston and other cities.
Can this gentle, humane culture survive the attritions of social media and the carceral state? In a way, it already has.
~Anthony Grafton, in an delightful LRB review-essay of Denise Gigante’s new book. 📚
Yeesh. For Minnesota United fans, things are not looking good on the Bebelo front.
Fortunately, we’ve been playing shockingly well without him. #MNUFC #COYL ⚽️
Currently reading: The Secret Commonwealth by Robert Kirk
A gloriously strange book from 17th-century Scotland. 📚
Blue Note Records is absolutely crushing it lately: Julian Lage, Charles Lloyd’s trio of trios, Bill Frisell’s new quartet, Gerald Clayton’s Bells on Sand, Ethan Iverson’s Every Note is True: seems like all my fav new albums are Blue Note.
And this week, new Walter Smith III and Kendrick Scott. 🎵
Current listening: Charles Lloyd, Trio of Trios 🎵
Three fantastic trio albums, each with a different cast of musicians alongside Lloyd: Thomas Morgan & Bill Frisell; Anthony Wilson & Gerard Clayton; Julian Lage & Zakir Hussain.
Current listening: Charles Lloyd, Trio of Trios. 🎵
Three fantastic trio albums, each with a different cast of musicians alongside Lloyd: Thomas Morgan & Bill Frisell; Anthony Wilson & Gerard Clayton; Julian Lage & Zakir Hussain.
No world / wears as well as it should but, mortal or not, / a world still had to be built.
~Auden, “The Birth of Architecture”